by Michell Bard, March 19, 2010
Dear Mr. President,

I wish to express my apology again to you for the embarrassing situation that occurred during Vice President Biden's visit to Jerusalem.  As I said to him and reiterate here, I did not know that the announcement of new construction in our capital was to be made and I have taken measures to ensure that such a mistake does not recur.  I understand your dismay at the timing and substance of the announcement and want to reassure you that my government is committed to maintaining and strengthening its longstanding alliance with the United States.

As your officials have been candid in expressing their views to me, I would like to be equally forthcoming in explaining our position.  we are dismayed and puzzled by statements from your administration suggesting that our government is not doing everything possible to achieve peace with its neighbors.

Your secretary of state [Hillary Rodham Clinton], who undiplomatically leaked to the press what was supposed to be a private conversation, surely recalls that during the administration of President Clinton, then Prime Minister Ehud Barak offered to create a Palestinian state in 97% of the West Bank and to dismantle most of the settlements as well as to make unprecedented compromises on Jerusalem.  The Palestinians rejected the offer.  As recently as two years ago, my predecessor offered the Palestinians a similar deal that they also rejected.  In fact, as our ambassador, historian Michael Oren, can easily document, it is the state of Israel that has repeatedly offered and made compromises in the interests of peace.

As you know, I have repeatedly expressed a willingness to sit down with the Palestinians and negotiate all outstanding issues.  It is their leadership, however, that has refused to come to the negotiating table.  I must add in all candor that their recalcitrance is in part related to your insistence on a settlement freeze that was never before a precondition for their participation in peace talks.  The Palestinians now have the impression that your administration will force Israel to capitulate to their demands, a view that has been reinforced by the uncharacteristic public attacks of the last week.

I am well aware of your position on settlements and want to assure you that the State of Israel has repeatedly shown it is prepared to take difficult and risky steps in the hope of peace.  Israel withdrew all of its settlements from the Sinai when Egypt made a commitment to full peace.  Just five years ago, Ariel Sharon removed every soldier and settler from Gaza in hope that this would prompt peace.  Unfortunately, the Palestinians once again missed an opportunity to build on our concession and move closer to peace by relentlessly attacking our country with terror rocket attacks.  In fact, Mr. President, more than 1000 Israeli citizens have been killed in three wars during this decade alone.  As a commander-in-chief fighting two wars, I know you can appreciate what this sacrifice means.

As a result of the Gaza experience, the people of Israel are in no mood to make new concessions to the Palestinians in the absence of gestures on their side that they are committed to peace.  But all we see is continued incitement, lately reflected in calls for a holy war against Israel, and belligerence.  Despite this, we hear no criticism of the Palestinians from your administration, again, giivng them the impression that they have nothing to concede in negotiatons because the United States is only interested in pressuring Israel.

I have imposed a freeze on settlement construction in the West Bank at your insistence, despite the difficulties this created for me politically.  The Palestinians did not reciprocate.  In fact, they hardened their position.

I must also respectfully decline your request to freeze construction in Jerusalem.  We are not building settlements; we are developing our capital.  When you or the Palestinians or anyone else suggests that we stop building in Jerusalem, I must be blunt and say that this is unacceptable and was unacceptable to my predecessors.

Israel values its longstanding special relationship with the United States and I can assure you that I am committed to working to strengthen that bond.  I am no less committed to achieving peace with our neighbors and will do everything within my power to reach an agreement at the negotiating table in direct talks with Palestinian leaders or any other Arabs who wish to participate.  We count on our friend and ally, the United States, to recognize this commitment to peace and to work with us to ensure that a resolution is achieved that provides peace and security for Israel and allows the Palestinians to create an independent state.


Benjamin Netanyahu
Return to Home page
Return to Archive Page